Skip to page content |

Tiscali Quicklinks. Please visit our Accessibility Page for a list of the Access Keys you can use to find your way around the site, skip directly to the main navigation, to the page content, or to more links within entertainment.

Advertisement starts



Advertisement ends

Content Starts Here


The Magdalene Sisters film review

THE MAGDALENE SISTERS
15certificate_15

THE MAGDALENE SISTERS


Running time: 120 mins
Starring: Geraldine McEwan, Anne-Marie Duff, Nora-Jane Noone, Dorothy Duffy, Eileen Walsh, Mary Murray
Tiscali Rating of 08Tiscali Rating of 08

With his first film My Name is Joe, writer/director and performer Peter Mullan showed that he was not afraid to tackle issues (in this case alcoholism) that would make most directors, let alone studios, quake in their boots. His new effort is again deserving of all the right adjectives: hard-hitting, unflinching, stark and often brutal. Since the film has already condemned by the Catholic Church we know there must be some good reason to view it, and while it is not an easy two hours to spend in the cinema the results are thought-provoking and worthwhile.

The film purports to tell the distinctly unsavory but true story of the Order of the Magdalene Sisters, a convent of Irish nuns so fierce that Mullan could have satisfactorily called his film Full Metal Habits. They terrorised Ireland, or at least the young girls of Ireland, until late into the last century. Their convents, ostensibly places where errant young women could find the path to salvation and Jesus were actually little more than prison camps where the inmates were subjected to regular humiliations, beatings and punishments that seem to have little in common with any of the Biblical teachings. Mullan adopts a simple but effective storytelling ruse: he follows the stories of three girls who arrived at the Dublin convent on the same day in 1964. All three were sent for spurious reasons: Margaret (Anne-Marie Duff) because she was raped and her family chose to believe it was her fault, Patricia (Dorothy Duffy) because she dared to have a baby out of wedlock and Bernadette (Nora-Jane Noone) simply because she occasionally flirted with a lad or two.

When the girls arrive their transformation is swift: forced to don pallid brown uniforms, their main occupation is to spend all day every day in the laundry, scrubbing in silence. Conditions are grim and it is clearly a place where the joy of Catholicism has turned its back. The film then charts the girls attempts to struggle against the system they have unjustly found themselves in and ideally manage to escape from the prison.

If one could pick a fault or two with Mullan they would be minor: the structure of the film becomes too obvious too quickly and while it is compulsive viewing none of what happens is particularly surprising. Also, anyone who grew up under the often oppressive religious atmosphere in Ireland - an atmosphere which still pervades across large sections of Irish society - would have a much greater understanding of the way in which religion was used to strike fear into the population and especially the young.

To be fair to Mullan he does address this latter issue to some extent and it may well have been the case that he didn't want to overpoliticise his film. Still, there are many things to savour, notably a shining cast of old hands (Geraldine McEwan is terrific as the ferocious Mother Superior) and novices (the three girls are all equally outstanding). The towering performance however comes from Eileen Walsh as the naïve and timid Crispina. An actress who shone in the little seen Janice Beard 45wpm, she delivers a simply astonishing turn. With The Magdalene Sisters Mullan firmly establishes himself as one of Britain's most important film-makers. It is tough and uncompromising cinema but ultimately provocative and highly rewarding.


page: 1 | 2
Search Our Reviews
Type the title of the film you want to find a review for in the box below and click on 'Search'
 
 
Click on the relevant letter to browse the film reviews in our database whose titles begins with that letter:

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z NUMBERS

Advertisement starts



Advertisement ends


Advertisement starts



Advertisement ends

Advertisement starts



Advertisement ends

Page Footer